059 Negation, Questions, and Do: One Analysis Explains Them All Where does the "do" in "did they arrive" come from? Why is there no inversion in "who ate an apple"? Reading the transformational machinery of chapter 7 of Syntactic Structures, one derivation at a time.
2026.09.12 058 The Limits of Phrase Structure: Why the Passive Can't Be a Rewrite Rule Phrase structure — sentences as boxes inside boxes — is stronger than the finite-state model. But conjunction, discontinuous auxiliaries, and the passive expose its limits. Reading chapters 4-5 of Syntactic Structures.
2026.09.12 057 "Colorless Green Ideas Sleep Furiously": Grammar Is Neither Meaning Nor Probability Why can't a machine that predicts each word from the last one ever generate English? Reading chapters 2-3 of Syntactic Structures through a concrete, nested example.
2026.09.12 056 Nine Ideas from Syntactic Structures, One at a Time From "what is a sentence" to "what should a theory aim at." The argument of Syntactic Structures, taken apart one piece at a time, each with a short example.
2026.09.12 055 Syntactic Structures, in Plain Words "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously" is a strange sentence — but it feels grammatical. Why? Following the question Chomsky's small book asked, with no jargon.
2026.09.12 054 Reading Chomsky's Syntactic Structures (1957): Grammar Is Independent of Meaning A young MIT teacher changed the landscape of linguistics with a slim, ninety-page book. You can't define a "grammatical sentence" by appeal to meaning, and you can't define it by appeal to probability either — so what do you appeal to? The book rejects a finite-state model, shows the limits of a phrase-structure model, and proposes a third model: the transformation. Read alongside "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously."
2026.09.12 053 The Relative Pronoun and the Hidden Sentence: How Many Judgments Fold Into One Word? Latin quorum, French que, Greek ὅτι — utterly different in shape, yet explained by a single principle. A relative pronoun can carry two roles at once, "pronoun" and "conjunction," or lean on just one of them. Reading the sequel to Chapter IX of Part II of the Port-Royal Grammar, through examples in Latin, Hebrew, and Greek.
2026.09.11